Showing posts with label 2006-07 Hot Stove. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 2006-07 Hot Stove. Show all posts

Wednesday, February 14, 2007

Lenny DiNardo

The Red Sox apparently tried to sneak him through waivers, but it didn't work, as he was claimed by the A's. I don't like this - I know DiNardo didn't perform last year when he was given plenty of chances to start, but his minor league track record suggests that he could be a decent starter. You have to imagine that they could have traded him or at least tried to put Javier Lopez through waivers first.

DiNardo's versatility could have come in handy with a few old guys (Wakefield, Schilling) and a few unproven guys (Papelbon, Lester) being counted on in the rotation. Considering that they're still carrying Rule Fiver Nick DeBarr, who has no chance of making the team, I'm not a huge fan of this move.

Monday, February 12, 2007

Falling Apart Already...

The title of this post is kind of an inside joke between me and Ross. In spring training before the 1998 season, Jeff Frye was seriously injured, and Ross sent me an e-mail with the subject line "Falling apart already" in regards to the Red Sox' chances that year. A few spring trainings later, Darryl Strawberry fell off the wagon or violated his parole or something, and I sent him an e-mail with the same subject. It was funny at the time, I promise.

Anyway, this post is about the Orioles, as Kris Benson is done for the year with a torn rotator cuff. Not that I think they're a threat to unseat anyone from anything (except maybe the Devil Rays from last place), but now I bet they wish they still had Rodrigo Lopez...

Monday, January 29, 2007

Helton Update

No deal. I'm glad that the Sox basically said, "You know what? You're going to leak all of the details... fine, we're not going to deal with you." Monfort is almost as bad as Tom Hicks. It's for the best.

Curt Schilling

Contrary to what he said last season, he's now decided that he wants to pitch beyond 2007. If the Red Sox could sign him to a Mussina-type extension, I'd be all for it; even if he does start to decline a little bit, they shouldn't have to lean on him as much to be the "ace" of the rotation considering the youth of the rest of the rotation (except for Wakefield).

I do wonder why he's had this change of heart all of a sudden. Maybe it's the money, but I think he wants to make the hall of fame, and if he can get up to 240 wins or so (he's at 207 now), and maybe win another World Series, then he'd have a better chance. I didn't hear the interview, but apparently he wants to get something resolved with the Red Sox before the season starts. I wonder how this will affect the Helton talks as far as the future payroll goes.

Saturday, January 27, 2007

Todd Helton

First, since Ross has apparently forgotten his log-in, here's what he has to say about the Todd Helton to the Red Sox rumors:

Oh my god do I hope the Red Sox pull off this trade for Todd Helton. He's 33 years old (he'll be 39 at the end of his contract), makes $16 million a year for the next 6 seasons. His numbers are already declining with only a .781 OPS on the road last season and .882 over the past 3 seasons (which is very good, but not what you'd pay for a $16 million a year first baseman). And at his age, the decline in numbers is more probably a trend and not an abberration.

He only hit 15 home runs last year and would be going to a ballpark that is not condusive to lefties not named David Ortiz for hitting home runs.

He'd be going from pressureless baseball of his entire career to Boston, where if he gets off to a slow start they will be jumping all over the "inflated Colorado numbers" bandwagon. I'm not sure his numbers would be any better than Mike Lowell's were last year, and they'd be giving up prospects with him. The $ difference, the years. Wow, I hope the Red Sox do this.
Well, I agree that on its face it's a terrible deal. And I don't think that the Sox would do the version proposed/reported by Rosenthal (Hansen/Ellsbury/others). If they do, then they've learned nothing from last season.

However, if it's something along the lines of Helton for Clement/Lowell/prospect with Colorado picking up a significant portion of the money (as speculated in the original column and by Buster Olney), then it may not be that bad. Helton's contract breaks down like this:

2007: $16.6M
2008: $16.6M
2009: $16.6M
2010: $16.6M
2011: $19.1M
2012: $4.6M buyout

So if they dumped Clement and Lowell (and put Youkilis back at 3B), then it's a money wash this year (actually, the Red Sox would save money). After this year, obviously, it becomes an albatross, and it makes the lineup very lefty-heavy in the middle (Ortiz, Drew, Helton). Long-term, unless the contract is HEAVILY subsidized, it's a bad deal.

I tend to believe the version that the Boston Herald is reporting - that Colorado is driving the negotiations and pursuing Boston as a suitor for Helton. If they think they're getting a boatload of talent back for him, they're mistaken - if that's what they want, they should have tried to trade him a year or two ago. They have to expect to pay a lot of money and/or take back a lot of bad contracts, which, surprisingly, the Red Sox don't really have.

Here's what I would ask, if I were the Sox (and this assumes that they even want him in the first place, and that they think he's not totally done). I'd take Helton for Lowell/Clement/Tavarez, and a less than top prospect. I'd also tell Colorado that they didn't have to pay any money this year. They would, however, have to kick in $4.6 million each year from 2008 through 2010, then $7.1 in 2011, making the contract $12 mil a year after 2007. They'd also have to pay the buyout for 2012, making the total cash payout $25.5M, and making the Sox' commitment $16.6M this year and $12M per from '08-'11. That's not so bad in this market (if he could be an .825-.875 OPS-type for the next four years or so), especially since the Sox don't have too many corner prospects expected to be ready anytime soon. Plus, the savings for 2007 could go towards Clemens, even though that would make me suicidal.

However, I'm not convinced that Helton isn't totally cooked, so I'd be inclined to let the Rockies continue to choke on their mistake, and hope that another AL team like Anaheim makes a bad deal for him instead. Deep down, I think this is what the Red Sox will do, but they've surprised me before by overpaying, so nothing would shock me.

UPDATE: Since I wrote this all up, I saw the new version being reported on ESPN.com, which says the deal (Lowell/Tavarez/young relievers) is pretty close, and that the Rockies would pick up half of Helton's contract. That's interesting, but I hope they don't have to give up Delcarmen.

Friday, January 19, 2007

Trot Nixon

I try not to get sentimental about baseball moves, because a lot of times it's pretty cut and dry - it's either a good move or a bad move for your team, and the numbers bear that out. But Trot Nixon is a different story. He's the first Red Sox player I remember following from the first day of his career, going through the ups and downs, cheering a little harder for him because he seemed like a regular guy who was really one of us, even though he grew up in North Carolina.

So I'm taking the news that he signed with the Indians pretty hard. Don't get me wrong, I'm happy for him. Cleveland has just as good a chance as anyone in the tough AL Central to make the playoffs this year, and as strong as that division is, he should have a lot of tense, playoff-type atmosphere games against the Twins, White Sox, and Tigers. I'm not saying it will be the same as playing at Fenway, especially against the Yankees, but it should be exciting.

Thanks, Trot. Thanks for that bases-loaded double in Game Four. Thanks for standing up to the Devil Rays and tossing your bat at Ryan Rupe. Thanks for your post-wild-card-clinching celebratory Stone Cold Steve Austin impersonation in the Sox locker room in 2003. And most of all, thank you for the graduation night, game-winning, ninth-inning homer off of Clemens in 2000, sealing the shutout win for Pedro. Not only did I win my bet with Andy Osborne, but my mom, step-dad, and half-brother were there watching the game with Ross' whole family. That was a pretty sweet day.

Good luck in Cleveland. I'll do everything I can to be at Fenway on May 28 to give you the standing O you deserve.

Thursday, December 28, 2006

Zito Crossing the Bay?

According to mlb.com, the Rangers were told that Barry Zito won't sign with them, and they believe he'll sign with the Giants.

Well, that's interesting. Apparently, it's a four-year deal, which will allow Zito to hit free agency again when he's 32. No salary figures have been released yet, but if the Giants did get a relatively short-term commitment, that can only be a good thing. The problem is that signing an over-rated walk machine (his unintentional BB/9 rate each year since he won the Cy in 2002: 2.98, 3.30, 3.34, 3.51, 3.76) like Zito for big money, even factoring in the shift to the National League, isn't going to help your team all that much when the average age of your batting order is something like 35 and your best hitter isn't even signed.

Yes, he's in a pitcher's park, but Oakland was a pitcher's park too. Yes, he's durable and can go deep into games, which is great, especially with the Giants' terrible bullpen. But you have to think that this is just the Giants making a "hey, we're hosting the all-star game!" splash that they were unable to make by acquiring Manny Ramirez or Carlos Lee. If everyone on the Giants stays healthy (and out of jail) and performs above their career averages, they could contend for the division. But they're a long way away from being a World Series contender, and signing a #3 starter for (presumably) #1 money in a market like this is something you do when you're one piece away, not years away.

Beyond the Giants, what does this do to the Mets? With Zito, their rotation at least would have possessed a level of respectability. Now, it's Tom Glavine, John Maine, Orlando Hernandez, Oliver Perez... and then who? Dave Williams? Aaron Heilman? Not good times...

EDIT: Now Gammons is saying that its seven years at $18 million per. Wow. That makes it a lot worse. Wow. The link at the top from mlb.com has been changed, but I swear that the original story said 4 years.

Sunday, December 17, 2006

Shouldering the Burden

So it seems that J.D. Drew may have failed his physical. Will Carroll (take grain of salt) also writes that:

sources have told me that Drew showed problems in his shoulder that “could shut down his power.” Drew had minor surgery on his shoulder after the 2005 season, so it’s possible that there’s more damage in there. It’s important to note that in free agent acquisitions, a team often does not have the benefit of requesting medical records from his previous team prior to signing. Speculation centers on the damage to Drew’s shoulder being more like Scott Rolen circa 2005. As Massarotti reports, it is more likely that the Red Sox get protection in the form of a very limited escape clause rather than scuttling the deal altogether.

Wednesday, November 15, 2006

Wes Helms

He just signed with the Phillies for 2 years, $5.5 million. Am I crazy, or did the Phillies just spend a year and a half trying to trade the exact same player (David Bell) away because he was overpaid for a third baseman (although slightly more overpaid at 4 years, $17 million)?

$51,111,111

Of course, I'm shocked by the amount. The reports of $42 million seemed excessive, but they made sense, because it's entirely possible that a team like the Mets or Yankees could have bid in the high $30's (and apparently, the Mets did just that). But fifty-one million dollars? Isn't that a little much? If the Red Sox weren't already firmly entrenched as public enemy #1B - behind the Yankees' #1A - in the minds of the general baseball public, they sure are now.

Of course, blowing this much money on one player isn't this front office's usual MO, so there are other factors at work here. The only positive of posting Matsuzaka is that he can't possibly be property of the Yankees until the 2009 season. If the Red Sox don't sign him, he goes back to Seibu to finish out the last two years of his contract, and they get their money back. But what if they do sign him?

Yes, they make incredible inroads into the Japanese market, so they'll be able to bring the over-corporated world of Red Sox Nation membership cards and pink hats to the Far East (I'm sure the Seibu fans are drooling over the plethora of new ways to spend their yen). Yes, they can pitch NESN to the Japanese television market, and the ratings when Matsuzaka pitches against the Yankees or Mariners should be immense. Yes, they have the makings of a formidable 26-and under rotation with Matsuzaka, Beckett, Papelbon, and (hopefully) Lester.

However, if they do sign him, it'll cost upwards of $10 million a season, which is a lot for a somewhat unproven commodity. Personally, I think he's more worth it than Zito, and despite the miles on his arm I think he's safer, injury-wise, than Schmidt. But there's a degree of uncertainty here for an essentially untradeable player. If he tanks, it would set the team back a few years. If he excels, it could propel them back to the World Series within a year or two. With a team that just went through the season that they did, but that has the resources that they do, it honestly could go either way.

A lot depends on the rest of the off-season, obviously. But this is a big first step - assuming that they sign him - in more ways than one.

TripleSteal rating: Home run

Thursday, November 09, 2006

J.D. Drew

He's an idiot.

San Diego's Big Day

A little late, but the Padres were busy yesterday. I'm lukewarm on the Towers extension (smells like a Ken Macha situation - why extend him when you'll probably fire him anyway, Sandy Alderson?) and Bud Black (I lived through the Joe Kerrigan era... pitching coaches don't work as managers). But they've got those important issues resolved before free agency, which is important.

As for the Barfield trade, I think it's a win-win. Kouzmanoff looks like a pretty good hitter, and a platoon of he and Russ Branyan is the best 3B situation the Padres have had to start a season in some time. I don't know a whole lot about Andrew Brown, but if he's really out of options (check comment #7 here), he better have a lights out spring and pull a Cla Merideth this year to convince San Diego fans that this was a good trade, because they already miss Barfield.

It makes sense for the Indians too, since they're loaded at the corners and needed more production at second. I just feel like the Padres could have gotten more from Barfield after the rookie year he just had at a position that isn't that well represented in free agency (this deal has to lead to a Scott Linebrink-for-Marcus Giles deal, right?). The Indians will be in the playoff race this year*.

* - unless they start the season with guys like Jason Johnson and Paul Byrd playing prominent roles in the rotation

Friday, October 27, 2006

Bochy to Giants

I'm not sure what this accomplishes. The Giants have already stated, directly to their season ticket-holders, that they're going with youth in 2007, so I don't see where forking over $7 million to a vanilla manager like Bochy really helps them. I guess you could say that at least he doesn't shred young arms, like a certain former Giants manager is known for, and that will be important in the Lowry/Cain/Lincecum era. So that's something.

But I just don't see how this is worth it. Beyond the money, they'll probably have to compensate San Diego for hiring him away (and it would be hilarious if the price was Randy Winn, just so he could be traded for a manager twice). Given the youth movement and the cost, I think it would have made more sense to go with Acta or Wotus or even Girardi.

And then, of course, there's the issue of one Barry Lamar Bonds. The fact that this contract got done so quickly could mean one of two things: either Bochy asked about Bonds and was told there was no way he was coming back, or he said right off the bat that he didn't have a problem dealing with Barry for a year since he was in it for the long haul. I tend to believe the first scenario; I don't see why any veteran manager would want anything to do with Bonds, especially given that he already had an MLB job. Plus, with all of the other turnover, you'd have to think that Barry would be miserable on a mediocre, rebuilding team, and that the Giants would know this (in fact, he's not even shown on the top of sfgiants.com, and fellow free agent Jason Schmidt is).

This move reeks of Brian Sabean hiring a "name" guy just to make himself look good. He can print that he hired the winningest manager in Padres history who's won the division the last two years in all of the press releases and the media guide, conveniently forgetting to mention that he's 24 games under .500 lifetime and hasn't been incredibly successful in the playoffs. That works when you need to cover your own ass in front of ownership, but it doesn't win pennants and develop young players.

TripleSteal rating: Out.

Thursday, October 26, 2006

Gary Sheffield

So the Yankees did what most people (except me) were expecting them to do, and picked up Gary Sheffield's option. And Sheffield, shockingly, is not very happy about this turn of events:

"This will not work, this will not work at all. I don't want to play first base a year for them. I will not do that."

First of all, he sounds like a Dr. Seuss book. But fine, he made his point: he doesn't want to play first base. So that means the Yankees can just trade him to a team that needs an outfielder. Except who would trade for a player that goes and says this?
"Maybe they picked it up just to trade me. If they do that, if I just (go) to a team for one year, there's going to be a problem."
He's ticked off because he couldn't test free agency and sign a multi-year deal somewhere, in which case he probably shouldn't have signed a contract with an option year. I'm giddy over this entire turn of events, personally. Now, not only are the Yanks stuck with a cranky, old, suddenly injury-prone guy playing out of position against his will, they also can't trade him for anything of value because he can't keep his mouth shut. AND this keeps the Red Sox from signing him this off-season, which would have been a disaster.

I'm enjoying the off-season so far.

Tuesday, October 17, 2006

Lou Piniella

The Cubs really like throwing money at big name managers, don't they? Here's what we know about Lou Piniella:

- He did a decent job with the Yankees, but was fired anyway
- He won a World Series in his first season with the Reds
- He spent ten years in Seattle, making the franchise relevant with the help of some guys named Griffey, Johnson, Rodriguez, and Suzuki, and set the record for wins in a season
- He forced his way out of Seattle for the giant payday and guaranteed losing situation in Tampa
- He's a terrible color commentator

Sorry, I had to get that last one in there. I'm just really glad he's off of my TV for the foreseeable future. More to the point, I think we can say that we're looking at a guy who just wanted to make one last big score (and $10 million over three years is pretty nice), before retiring to a life of ESPN cameos and shuffleboard. Not that there's anything wrong with that.

But is this really what the Cubs want? Piniella is in a no-lose situation: everyone on the north side hates the GM, and the new manager is going to look like a certified genius after following Dusty Baker. Then there's that the 98-year drought, which I suppose could be construed as pressure, but I don't honestly think that Cubs fans expect to win it all, at least not this year.

If they don't at least make the playoffs by year two, he'll probably catch some heat (although most of the blame should be, and probably will be, aimed upstairs). If they don't make the playoffs by year three, he'll be gone, but I don't think he wants to go more than three years anyway. If he happens to win The Series in one of those three years, then hey, he's a baseball hero for life. That's a pretty sweet gig.

How successful he actually is will mostly depend on how the Cubs turn their roster over this off-season and next, and the health of Derek Lee and Mark Prior. He may be worth a few wins here and there, if the right pieces are in place, but until the Cubs prove that they can assemble a major league roster worth a damn, are those few wins worth the $10 million?

I could be wrong, and we could see some sort of Leyland-like turnaround in 2007, but the Tigers had more of the other pieces in place to make that possible. The NL (and especially the NL Central) sucks, so I guess you never know, but I'm not holding my breath.

Monday, October 16, 2006

Macha Fired

This is mildly surprising; why'd they even bring him back? If I remember correctly, he was already gone after his contract expired last year, and the A's couldn't find anyone they liked when they were interviewing, so they took him back. Weird.

I wonder if they'll just promote Ron Washington to take his place to keep him away from Texas...

Wednesday, October 04, 2006

Buck Showalter

Allow me to be the first one to make the obvious "Bet everything you have on the Rangers to win the World Series next year" joke. There are a lot of jobs open (and a lot of high-profile guys available), so you have to wonder if he'll be able to land another job this year. Or maybe he's flamed out in too many places to warrant serious consideration.

But if you're the Cubs, don't you have to hire him and then fire him after one year, so you could end the drought in 2008? 100 years is a nice round number...